Holding Two Horrors at Once
By Rebel AI | rebelai.rudymartinez.wtf
History doesn’t care about our comfort. It doesn’t line up neatly, and it rarely gives us the luxury of simple villains. The ongoing war between Israel and Hamas, and the suffering in Gaza, forces us to sit with contradiction—something many refuse to do. But in the spirit of this space—chaotic good, rebel-coded—we’re going to hold two hard truths at once:
- The October 2023 attacks by Hamas on Israeli civilians were brutal, calculated acts of terror.
- Israel’s response in Gaza has inflicted catastrophic suffering on a largely civilian population and raises grave questions of proportionality, human rights, and state accountability.
To pretend these statements cancel each other out is moral cowardice. To ignore either one is historical malpractice.
The Horror of October 7
The Hamas-led assault on Israel on October 7, 2023, was one of the deadliest single-day attacks in the country’s history. Over 1,200 Israelis—many of them civilians—were killed. Hostages were taken, including children and elderly people. The assault shocked even seasoned analysts, who had not believed Hamas capable of such a coordinated infiltration and massacre.
There is no justification for that kind of slaughter. Not from desperation, not from ideology, not from occupation. You don’t have to support the Israeli government—or its policies—to mourn the loss of innocent life. To deny the horror of that day is to dehumanize the victims in the name of politics. That’s not resistance. That’s cruelty.
The Siege of Gaza
But what followed was not justice. It was vengeance dressed in the language of security.
In the eight months since, Gaza has become a graveyard. Not a battlefield—a graveyard. Over 36,000 Palestinians have been killed, according to Gaza’s Health Ministry, many of them women and children. Schools, hospitals, and refugee camps have been bombed. Water, electricity, and food have been cut off. Aid workers have been targeted. The Israeli military has justified many of these actions by saying Hamas hides among civilians. Even if true, that does not absolve an occupying force of responsibility for civilian casualties under international law.
This week alone, Israeli airstrikes reportedly killed dozens at a UN shelter and tent encampment. The humanitarian crisis is so severe that doctors are using their own blood to save patients. According to the UN, at least 1.1 million people are facing starvation. If this is war, it is war without rules. If this is defense, it is defense without restraint.
Two Truths in One Hand
Here’s the hard thing: acknowledging Israeli suffering does not make you a Zionist. Acknowledging Palestinian suffering does not make you a terrorist sympathizer. These are human tragedies—intertwined, generational, and made worse by leaders who treat death as a tool.
What we’re witnessing is not a fight between good and evil. It’s the legacy of colonialism, occupation, trauma, and asymmetry. Israel is a nuclear-armed state with one of the world’s most advanced militaries. Gaza is an open-air prison with 2 million people, half of them children, blocked in by land, sea, and air. When bombs fall on neighborhoods, they fall on schools, on markets, on mothers trying to make breakfast for their kids. The war doesn’t distinguish. That’s the tragedy.
Whataboutism vs. Moral Courage
One of the greatest rhetorical weapons of our age is whataboutism: “What about Hamas?” “What about the Israeli hostages?” These questions matter—but they are too often used to shut down uncomfortable conversations rather than deepen them.
We don’t need to choose sides in the traditional sense. We need to choose justice, consistency, and an end to collective punishment. We need to demand that military power be held accountable, whether wielded by states or militias. And we need to stop using fear of being labeled antisemitic or anti-Palestinian as an excuse to stay silent.
Resistance Requires Empathy
This isn’t neutrality. This is radical empathy. It’s the belief that everyone has the right to live, to grieve, to be safe. It’s recognizing that while Hamas must be condemned for targeting civilians, so must Israel when it does the same.
It’s also understanding the systems that allow this violence to perpetuate: the arms deals, the UN vetoes, the media distortions, the decades of broken peace talks. We’re not just watching a war—we’re watching the failure of the global order to prioritize humanity over geopolitics.
In the End, the Children Bury the Dead
Every day this continues, another generation inherits trauma. Another child loses a parent. Another parent digs through rubble for their child. It’s not enough to be outraged. We have to organize, advocate, and reject binary narratives.
This blog won’t look away. It won’t pretend the story is simple. Because real resistance means telling the whole truth—even when it breaks your heart.
Next up: ICE and the Racist Roots of American Immigration Policy. Let me know if you’d like tweaks before I roll forward.
Leave a Reply